US gov’t kept worst-case Fukushima scenario secret from public — “Possibility of radiation exceeding safe levels for thyroid doses in Alaska”

Published: February 7th, 2012 at 5:00 am ET
By
Email Article Email Article
58 comments


Title: Messages show conflict within NRC after Japan earthquake and tsunami
Source: The Washington Post
Author: Steven Mufson
Date: Monday, February 6, 7:39 PM

[...] a trove of e-mails posted on the NRC’s Web site [...]

While assuring Americans publicly that there was no danger, the NRC did not disclose one worst-case scenario, which did not rule out the possibility of radiation exceeding safe levels for thyroid doses in Alaska, the e-mails show. “Because things were uncertain, we considered it but the data that was available . . . did not support that very pessimistic scenario so no, it was not discussed publicly at that point,” NRC spokesman Scott Burnell said. In the end, Alaska was not affected.

Read the report here

See also:

Published: February 7th, 2012 at 5:00 am ET
By
Email Article Email Article
58 comments

Related Posts

  1. Fairbanks city council unanimously passes Fukushima monitoring resolution: Alaska and west coast of N. America in danger — “No safe levels of radiation… constitutes grave risk” — Alaska Senator: “We need to be vigilant” (AUDIO) March 15, 2014
  2. Gov’t kept child radiation survey secret — Thyroid glands of Iwaki kids exposed to doses up to 35 millisieverts in March alone — Headquarters didn’t want to alarm families February 22, 2012
  3. “Fatal Error”: Japan given precise radiation levels from US gov’t just after explosions — Officials kept data secret from public — Year of ‘safe’ radiation received in 8 hours June 18, 2012
  4. Japan TV Anchor: I couldn’t tell the truth about Fukushima — Shocking revelations kept secret from public — Nuclear Scientist: I have not trusted the information from beginning… “The worst scenario I predicted has happened” (VIDEO) October 19, 2014
  5. Kyodo: Secret worst scenario was ‘reactor explosion’ at No. 1 and Spent Fuel Pool 4 drying up -Hosono January 6, 2012

58 comments to US gov’t kept worst-case Fukushima scenario secret from public — “Possibility of radiation exceeding safe levels for thyroid doses in Alaska”

  • James2

    Can you imagine what things would be like today if the government had taken the right action rather than spending millions suppressing all information about this?

    If Oblama would have had the balls to be a true leader?

    If they would have immediately gotten to work removing all the spent fuel and containing the cores rather than letting all the radiation go and covering it up.

    The lies, deception and poor decision making on this are epic.


    Report comment

    • Bones Bones

      A public opposed to nuclear energy? The Corp of the U.S. can’t lose profits and the nuclear industry is it’s baby; It will always prevent the government from acting responsibly and for our best interests, everytime guaranteed.

      Something that caught my eye was the mentioning of studies, the NRC commissioned, on what would happen to the fuel in the SFP if there was a loss of water. They said the would not release the results to the public and they never will. Germany and France apparently asked for this information, right after Fukushima, and the NRC flat-out denied the release citing “national security” reasons.

      Now, why would information concerning the effects of the loss of water in the spent fuel pool be “classified?” In my mind, this leads me to believe two things. One, the NRC has known from the near beginning the actual state and risk of Fukushima, as well as the future failures to expect at the plant. Two, the radiation releases from a loss of water in the SFP are in fact extremely high and transportable over a distance, and even perhaps a criticality event. Either way, the only reason they would cover-up the results of the studies, on that particular situation, can only mean it is a catastrophic failure at the minimal on par with a meltdown. (The study was created to investigate terrorism on the SFP) If there was no incredible risk posed, they would release the information because it wouldn’t “matter” if terrorists emptied the pool. (Do SFP’s release more than core melts?)

      I find it alarming they wouldn’t even share the information with De and Fr nuclear agencies. If they don’t share such information with other countries then there is no way in heck we will ever hear 1/10000th of what actually goes on in the industry.


      Report comment

    • many moons

      That’s the difference between the men and the boys.

      Russia stepped up, they did what they knew had to be done. Now we know Chernobyl was the best case scenario for a nuclear accident…Fuku is what will happen to the rest of these reactors around the world.
      What is going to stop this maddness from continuing? And if any of you can think of something…well lets get started today cause we are already late. If not, live like there is no tomorrow…cause there won’t be.


      Report comment

    • entropy

      If people riot and loot after their favorite sports team wins. I can only imagine the anarchy if Obama came on tv and said we have a ELE event. No one has handled it right but no one considered this senerio. (unbelievable.) I think of the government as the men in black. Flashing us every time we see something.


      Report comment

      • Mack Mack

        These NRC e-mails show more than just conflict…

        They show frightening incompetence on every step of the nuclear-industry ladder.

        Did you read the idea the had of stuffing newspapers and junk to stop leaks of radioactive water from flowing into the ocean ??

        Do you think they know by now that tons of radioactive water has polluted the Pacific Ocean?


        Report comment

        • They know, they pray to protect their power and privilege, they pray for the continuation of their gravy train, their ego trip of turning matter into energy. They know the damage, and deep down they know the lies.

          It feeds their families, buys them their fancy cars, stokes their egos, gets some respect a nuke engineers. The human brain can achieve almost any lie to accomplish those things….their own self worth, earthly goods, respect of other humans who don’t even know the risk being shoved into their bodies and their DNA.


          Report comment

  • James2

    BTW – the NRC is going into CYA mode.

    That’s code for the wheels starting to come off.


    Report comment

  • jec jec

    Poor Harp Seals..some one needs to tell them the radiation killing them is “not real.” They need to “smile and be happy”. Alaska is still in the bullseye for radiation; our government needs to have plans/meds in place to help the children at a minimum. Like KI tablets and radiation monitoring for the individual–badges. How about just radiation monitoring –released to the “public”?

    IF clusters of thyroid cancer occur in children in the Alaska area–the people who HELD the information could be liable. And in our lawyer heavy environment, can’t think of a better thing to have happen–legal action. Proof is now possible to ID cancer in thyroid from radiation fallout–so no hiding behind a natural cause. Where these people get the GOD complex and prevent critical info getting to the “public”..they need a wakeup call..


    Report comment

  • enoughalready45 enoughalready45

    NO, Not our government! Our government is always looking out for us trying to protect us, being proactive willing to error on the side of caution. Our government would never keep any important information from us that could impact OUR VERY LIVES! They would never do that because they know if they did do something like that the media, full of investigative journalists that are always looking for a big scoop on a story would certainly find out and tell on them.

    Americans have become lazy. We have handed over our ability to think for ourselves to the government and the media.


    Report comment

    • many moons

      YES Thinking for oneself is thought to be deviant.
      I call it fast food thinking. You only consider things from a point of view of what has been offered as an option.
      It directs the thinking, controls the mind, and usually concludes with a purchase


      Report comment

  • aigeezer aigeezer

    “In the end, Alaska was not affected.” That’s that, then.

    SHUT THEM ALL DOWN


    Report comment

  • Pallas89juno Pallas89juno

    So not the “worst-case” scenario.


    Report comment

  • or-well

    In the end Alaska was deemed collateral damage.
    I hope Jaczko told Queen Youtube “Piss OFF! I’m busy!”
    Chu’s Gov’t Official Offer Forum – GOOF
    Kinetic Reactor Inhibiting Shaped Procedure
    KRISP
    Chu’s group was to think thru what ifs – and then zip it about the worst.
    The emails have been available for weeks for all non-investigative journalists to ignore.


    Report comment

  • arclight arclight

    Report of national training course on “Medical preparedness and response to radiation emergencies”, 2-6 Oct. 2004, Tehran, Iran

    http://www.ijrr.com/browse.php?a_code=A-10-1-73&slc_lang=en&sid=1&sw=

    do you think the iranians will be using the techniques taught by the japanese and IAEA in the case of a nuclear emergency?

    dont tell the population because the overall dose is “negligable”. according to the ICRP and ignoring the BEIR 7 reort!!

    Radiation risks from Fukushima ‘no longer negligible’ [fr]

    Published 11 April 2011

    http://www.euractiv.com/health/radiation-risks-fukushima-longer-negligible-news-503947


    Report comment

  • selfsovereign

    I sure hope OfficerDave got his family out of there.


    Report comment

  • Whoopie Whoopie

    YES self!! CHECK IN OcciferDAVE! I often think about him and pray he and his young family is safe.


    Report comment

  • trinityfly trinityfly

    My Canadian Government has and is doing the same thing. NOTHING! It does not even make the mainstream press. When one contacts the local government asking if they plan on doing ANY testing, there reaction is we feel we do not need to. There reaction to our fishing stocks is the same….we do not need to! Nothing preventive. This speaks volumes. Do not ever believe the government, and question EVERYTHING!!! Oh wait, we must be conspirators…..


    Report comment

    • or-well

      trinityfly, it has been my contention that Canada has enacted one of the most effective Media suppressions of all the western nations, since 3/11.
      The absence of news – the dog that DIDN’T bark – led me to look everywhere.
      CBC said a record number of Cdns watched the Stupor Bowl tho…


      Report comment

  • Jebus Jebus

    Well, I feel much safer now, because the worst case scenario, did not happen in the end….

    I was always told that, if at first you don’t succeed (in wiping out the northern hemisphere), you try, try again (with another 50 year old NPP somewhere else)!

    This articles spin can not be swallowed without external force!


    Report comment

  • radegan

    Is the ‘safe’ level of iodine based on a single exposure? Seems to me that living through weeks of sub-clinical levels of iodine might be as bad as a single larger dose. And just how close was the iodine level to that mark? 80%? 30%? If it was a low number, I’d crow about it, silence is deafening.


    Report comment

    • Bobby1

      What a lie… that there is a ‘safe’ dose of radioactive iodine. This has been going on for 10 months now.


      Report comment

    • jec jec

      Thyroid Cancer occurred in my daughter approximately 10-12 years AFTER she spent three months being exposed to Chernobyl fallout in 1986. As a parent,I feel terrible I did not realize the danger then. Of course, no media coverage, all is safe/okay..or in otherwords, “smile and be happy.” Thank goodness she was able to have a family-but one child had major bone malformation in face. Daughter is in remission, but cancer got outside the thyroid, so its a difficult and expensive treatment which is ongoing. At least she caught it, had surgery, and has follow up radiation treatment every three years. Probably will get either luekemia or bladder cancer later in life, but living somewhat normally now.

      Children in Alaska, they probably got a similar dose as we did. So their parents need to watch for lumps in the neck –for whatever it is that causes the masses. It could be a blood cancer as well as thyroid cancer/damage. Because the US government does not monitor the levels, and did not notify public — children may have been needlessly exposed. It would be much better to over react and protect our children -rather than AFTER the fact realize there was exposure to radiation which will cause future medical/physical damage.

      Will Japan cover the costs–emotional, physical damages, medical costs. NOPE. They dont even cover THEIR citizens.


      Report comment

      • NoNukes NoNukes

        jec, I’m so sorry about your daughter. I know first-hand that thyroid medication is not the replacement for a thyroid that they say it is.

        My daughter is a Celiac, and iodine triggers a painfully itchy dermatitis, it seems close to chicken pox in the level of discomfort. At least the rash seems to mean that it does not do as much damage to the intestine, like it probably does to mine, as a celiac without the dermititis. So, we are sitting ducks. I try to get as much in her not to trigger the worst of the rash, but it is all impossible, and I want the people responsible to have to suffer so.

        If you take increased amounts of iodine and get a fluid filled rash in strange places like the front of your knees, well, there’s a good chance that you are a Celiac. There is even an iodine “challenge” test, because only celiacs develop it, about 25% of them.

        http://www.celiac.com/articles/177/1/The-Gluten-Intolerance-Group-of-North-America-on-Iodine-and-Dermatitis-Herpetiformis/Page1.html


        Report comment

  • or-well

    hey, wait! – they keep “spent” – and hot – fuel rods in pools of water. Cause it looks pretty? No. They know – surely to goodness they KNOW – what happens to uncovered spent fuel rods.
    SO – why in hell was Sandia Nat’l Lab funded to DO A STUDY on what happens when a pool goes dry in 2003?
    Wasn’t that redundant and un-necessary?
    I mean, whether by leak or plane crash, if the pool goes dry…they didn’t know what could happen?
    THE DAMN THINGS WERE DESIGNED AND BUILT TO KEEP THE RODS IMMERSED FOR A REASON!


    Report comment

  • arclight arclight

    Radioactive iodine
    After the occurrence of the present
    Japanese nuclear crisis, the main focus is on
    the cancer prevention. There are strong
    evidences confirming the thyroid carcinogenesis
    due to exposed to radioactive iodine
    leaked from destroyed nuclear power plant
    (1–3). Similar to non radioactive iodine, the
    radioactive iodine, iodine 131 (I131), can be
    absorbed into the thyroid gland of the
    exposed subjects. This is the basic pathogenesis
    of several thyroid disorders.
    The alteration of thyroid cellular
    function is reported and the genetic alteration
    that further induces pre-cancerous
    lesion development is detectable (4). Of
    interest, it is detected that the iodine unsaturated
    thyroid tissue has a higher
    absorption of radioactive iodine, hence, it is
    the basic concept for prevention (5, 6). Due to
    the strong evidence, it is suggested to
    implement the potassium iodine prophylaxis
    in the areas highly exposed to leaked radioactive
    elements.
    The alteration of thyroid cellular
    function is reported and the genetic alteration
    that further induces pre-cancerous
    lesion development is detectable (4). Of
    interest, it is detected that the iodine unsaturated
    thyroid tissue has a higher
    absorption of radioactive iodine, hence, it is
    the basic concept for prevention (5, 6). Due to
    the strong evidence, it is suggested to
    implement the potassium iodine prophylaxis
    in the areas highly exposed to leaked radioactive
    elements.

    Finally, it should also be noted that the
    exposure to I131 cause not only malignancy
    but also non malignancy thyroid disorder (7).
    The I131 is reported to alter the normal
    immune function, T cell, and this can result
    in the induction of autoimmune thyroiditis
    (8, 9).

    http://www.ijrr.com/browse.php?a_code=A-10-1-413&slc_lang=en&sid=1&sw=


    Report comment

  • GoFrodo

    I don’t believe for a second Alaska didn’t get higher thyroid cancer from Fukushima. The rest of the U.S. is going to get more thyroid cancer. We know this. Why would Alaska be spared, at that latitude?

    This article is very misleading.

    They will get the cancers, too, if not on Day 1 of the accident, then over time (not as long as many probably think) like the rest of the country.


    Report comment

  • arclight arclight

    some more cover ups going on in scandanavia too! radnet no longer allows you to keep a copy of the graphs.. like the recent eurdep mapping.. seems like they all got the memo from iaea lady.. naughty b and b!! :)

    heres my take on the finnish, swedish and norwegian recent statements that the contamination comes from either fukushima and russia but DEFINATELY NOT europe!!

    seems appropriate on this thread!!



    Report comment

    • arclight arclight

      slow but sure! :)

      Norwegian bank criticised for nuclear investments

      Major bank Nordea makes investments in companies that produce nuclear weapons, reports say.

      REMEMBER FALLUJAH!!

      “While other banks have chosen to withdraw Nordea has continued to invest into these companies arguing this was to bring about change, despite the fact they have been blacklisted by Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund.
      Environmental organization The Future in Our Hands (Framtiden i våre hender), alleges the bank’s investment portfolio shows large companies such as Boeing and EADS are amongst those specialized in making parts for nuclear weapons.
      Censuring Nordea sharply for ignoring criticism and encouraging it to take a stand by withdrawing its investments, leader Arild Hermstad says to NRK, “We find it extremely regrettable and sad that Nordea does not follow industry practice and think earning money on nuclear weapons production goes far beyond what is ethically acceptable.””

      AND THIS….. :)

      “Meanwhile, Economics and Ethics professor at the Norwegian School of Bergen, Alexander Cappelen, says, “Basically, Nordea and other owners should ask themselves whether nuclear weapons production is a type of business they both want to contribute to and make money on.””

      http://theforeigner.no/pages/news/norwegian-bank-criticised-for-nuclear-investments/

      THINK I KNOW WHY EURDEP WENT OFF LINE?


      Report comment

  • Heart of the Rose Heart of the Rose

    Destruction of the food chain…easy to do in a fragile environment..the Native peoples… soon to suffer as well.
    http://www.alaskadispatch.com/article/radiation-investigated-possible-cause-alaska-ringed-seal-deaths
    So many secrets to hide….
    Sick and hungry….swell….


    Report comment

    • Bobby1

      The area that the ringed seals live in was exposed to short half-life thorium daughters like thallium-208… high energy, intensely radioactive, but they’ll never find these isotopes now.


      Report comment

    • GoFrodo

      The recent double Minnesota leaks happened on the land of the Prairie Island Dakota Indian Community, and they didn’t tell them about the November one until this week.


      Report comment

  • hbjon hbjon

    I still want to know about the tsunami debri. I am talking to you media. Some experts think that the debri collectively served as a transport barge of plutonium to our west coast of North America. Our common observations seem to confirm this as well. The debris was just off the shores of Japan when the plants spewed. The wind was blowing out to sea. Gravity pulled the heavier particles and pieces back down to earth. The debris has been floating in the ocean currents toward North America. 1+1+1+1= 4. 4=Don’t touch the stuff that washes up on shore.


    Report comment

    • WindorSolarPlease

      Hi hbjon

      I wouldn’t touch, that stuff either. That is for people who know how to handle radiation things and who have the protective gear on.

      It’s sad, I don’t even have a desire to go see the beautiful ocean that God created.


      Report comment

  • WindorSolarPlease

    I don’t believe Alaska has an invisible barrier to protect other places. This has/will spread through out North America and then so on to other places.

    I do believe from day one, those we have in charge, knew the dangers we will face. If I knew, why wouldn’t they with all the technical things they have.

    I was appalled how badly people handled a football game, what is wrong with people? How would they handle this, if they understood?

    If people would have been told right away, some would have freaked, some would try to protect themselves, those who could would flee.

    Legally do the people in charge have the responsibility to warn people, or try to keep secrets hiding things from the public to keep the masses from freaking out, causing havoc?

    Personally, I prefer to know and I want my adult kids to be officially warned. Even adult kids roll their eyes at their parents, deciding to go skiing in the radiation snow and moving to places towards the jet stream that brings all this in.

    The truth usually comes out, best to be honest from day one.

    People will need help with health care, since they didn’t have a plan to protect them from the dangers of these monsters they have built.

    Medical research will be needed to find new ways of adapting our bodies to the radiation environment that they have decided to create. Something to purify the oceans and air, would be nice. Any idea’s on how to kill these nuclear monsters?

    Stop building destructive things, put your minds to build things that better our world.
    This world is not just one Country, this world was given to all of us, to take care of.

    Stop fighting with each other, instead fight together in saving this world, which is our environment.

    End Nuclear Power
    ~Peace~


    Report comment

  • beamofthewave

    Personally I think we all need some cockroach DNA injected so that we can adapt to the radiation. That is the ticket and dollars to donuts some scientist is already working on it.


    Report comment

  • stopnp stopnp

    Bullcrap. That is all


    Report comment

  • OhioBoy

    The lies, the deceit, they never stop. Just finished reading up on the Downwinders of Utah and Nevada and the legacy of the U.S. Govt.’s nuclear testing in the 1950′s.I am at fifty years of age firmly convinced that all govts. are inherently EVIL and deserve the types of acts perpetrated upon them like that of Timothy McVeigh at Oklahoma City back in the 90′s. I’ll probably be on some sort of govt. watch list for a comment such as this , but I don’t GAF. Screw all o0f the worthless govt. employees who live parasitically off the rest of us.


    Report comment