Internal NRC emails on Mar. 15: “Are we still looking at a possible total meltdown and big release” from Fukushima? — As US regulator was debating whether Level 4 or 5 accident… Ended up Level 7, the highest

Published: November 17th, 2011 at 5:29 pm ET
By
Email Article Email Article
37 comments


March 15th, 2011 – Are we still looking at a possible total meltdown and big release?, Enformable, Nov. 17, 2011:

From: Astwood. Heather
Date: Tuesday, March 15, 2011 4:00 PM

[...] Are we still looking at a possible total meltdown and big release? [...]

March 15th, 2011 – NRC debates INES levels 3 days prior to actual upgrade to Level 5, Enformable, Nov. 17, 2011:

From: Sigmon, Rebecca
Sent: Tuesday, March 15, 2011 3:20 PM

[...] NISA didn’t give much (any) explanation of their [Level 4 INES] rating that I saw, but my impression is that it was based on radiation levels measured at the site boundary and the potential for exposure to the general public.

And that was before things took a decided turn for the worse over the weekend.

At this point I think there’s so much that we don’t know about what’s going on, but I think a final rating of at least a 5 is likely. [...]

INES I don’t think anticipated the common cause effects on multiple units – does the fact that they’re dealing with potential fuel damage at 3 or even 4 different units on the same site affect the rating? It certainly complicates the response.

From: Jones, Cynthia
Sent: Tuesday, March 15, 2011 3:47 PM

I agree with you that its probably a level 5 but told the ExecTeam that Japan had not changed their INES rating nor increased the level despite IRSN and Canadian press indicating that they had. [...]

Published: November 17th, 2011 at 5:29 pm ET
By
Email Article Email Article
37 comments

Related Posts

  1. “Just the tip of the iceberg”: Van emitting 110 uSv/hr — Ended up 370 miles from Fukushima in Kobe — “Dangerously radioactive” vehicles must be resold within Japan October 25, 2011
  2. US Regulator: We’ve got to stop labs from testing for Fukushima radiation — “Tell them to back off” — Worried about them talking to press about ‘consequences’ March 2, 2012
  3. Economist: Composition of radionuclides may be more dangerous at Fukushima than Chernobyl, according to bird study — Population reduction twice as large after Japan meltdowns March 1, 2012
  4. Alarm sounds at newly restarted Japan nuclear plant: Warning that “water level in tank fell at least 10 cm” from normal — More water injected ‘just in case’ — Officials apologize for delayed disclosure (VIDEO) June 20, 2012
  5. Radiation dose spikes in Ibaraki northeast of Tokyo near time of last night’s 5 intensity quake — Highest level measured since April — Double average January 23, 2012

37 comments to Internal NRC emails on Mar. 15: “Are we still looking at a possible total meltdown and big release” from Fukushima? — As US regulator was debating whether Level 4 or 5 accident… Ended up Level 7, the highest

  • dpl dpl

    nuke reg retard #1
    if we go see what is going on in FUKU then we would have to give a realistic rating for the accident.
    nuke reg retard #2
    boy I’m sure glad we don’t have to go then.

    Fascinating isn’t one of the words I would expect to hear from the knuckleheads at NRC to describe this CF event.
    Now that it’s settled at 10% of Chernobyl and nobody died ,they can change the rating back to a 5. MISSION ACCOMPLISHED


    Report comment

    • ion jean ion jean

      What a couple of useless, overpaid paper pushers!

      These two should just spend a week in the Cascade Mountains or Alaska and see what it does to their ovaries…

      Then they might not be so nonchalant. See, this is the probleM with these govt. Agencies and why they need to be totally abolished.


      Report comment

  • http://www.king5.com/news/local/Baby-orca-found-dead-on-Washington-beach-133961633.html

    Baby orca found dead on Washington beach

    PORTLAND, Ore. — Seaside Aquarium says a newborn orca found dead on the Washington coast died of a stomach hernia and was not stillborn.

    KVAL reports the 8-foot carcass washed ashore Monday near Seaview and was recovered by a wildlife officer. He transferred it to the Seaside Aquarium manager for a necropsy by marine mammal experts at Portland State University.

    They’ll try to determine whether the whale comes from a resident or transient pod.

    The aquarium says baby orca is quite valuable for researchers. It’s the first newborn killer whale to wash ashore in the area in the aquarium’s 16-year involvement with the stranding network.


    Report comment

    • It also still had the umbilical cord attached !

      The young female, with her umbilical cord still attached, was found dead …
      http://m.kitsapsun.com/news/2011/nov/16/dead-baby-orca-will-provide-scientific/


      Report comment

      • midwestern midwestern

        What is killing killer whales?
        http://www.bbc.co.uk/nature/14663732
        “Marine experts are concerned about an invisible threat to the animals that has been building in our seas since World War II.”


        Report comment

        • midwestern midwestern

          They overlooked the other killer accumulating in our waters since WWII.


          Report comment

        • @ midwestern, From article:
          “Not much is known therefore about the causes of orca’s deaths and what, if any, pollutants are in their bodies.”

          Orca’s, Killer whales eat seals also and numbers of seals have been dieing in Northern sea’s …

          Disease is Unknown hiting Alaska ringed seals, elsewhere also
          To Mass Animal Death on Friday, October 14, 2011
          http://members.beforeitsnews.com/story/1233/861/

          Perhapes there is a link or it could be something more recent ! Pacific nuclear testing …

          Pacific Proving Grounds – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
          … and underwater nuclear weapons, and so no further U.S. tests were conducted at the Pacific Proving Grounds, …
          http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_Proving_Grounds

          and the …

          Dumping Radioactive Waste at Sea, Radiation Legacy
          To Mass Animal Death on Friday, November 11, 2011
          http://members.beforeitsnews.com/story/1356/501/

          As well as …

          Great Pacific Garbage Patch – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

          The north Pacific Garbage Patch on a continuous ocean map … draws in waste material from across the North Pacific Ocean, including coastal waters … a year of entering the water, leaching potentially toxic chemicals such as bisphenol A, …. ”
          The world’s rubbish dump: a tip that stretches from Hawaii to Japan,” Kathy Marks …
          http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_Garbage_Patch

          And there is this …

          The former Soviet Union and, now Russia, have reportedly
          dumped radioactive waste in the Sea of Japan since 1950s. A report
          of an environmental group, Greenpeace, first revealed the
          surprising fact in February 1993, and Russian authorities admitted
          it the following month.1 Even then, the Russian navy audaciously
          dumped 900 tons of low level liquid nuclear waste directly in the
          Sea of Japan in October, 1993.2 In the face of strong resentment in
          Japan, the United States and other countries, the Russian …
          http://www1.american.edu/TED/japansea.htm


          Report comment

          • I am 100% certain these recent deaths are attributed to fukushima in one way or another. These colossal creatures, feed among the seals, and the seals among the fish.

            There is obviously a link between the oceanic contamination. As these species do not share the correct genes to speculate biological reasoning.

            In short. A monkey can not eat a cricket with aids and receive the hiv virus. As they do not share enough common genetic sequences to pass on the virus.

            This also goes for Whale vs Seal. As the two have very distinct genetic sequences which Are biologically impossibilities to blame a Flu / viral infection.

            This leaves only one solution:
            Environmental contamination.

            The animals are sharing only one trait. Consumption.
            They are in a food chain. Fish eat anything from fish to smaller bacteria. Seals eat fish whales eat seals.

            That is how theses species are connected. That is how this Cycle is taking place.
            This can not be a viral / genetically passive trait. Therefore contamination of environment is the only respectable theory to be represented.

            Was there a change in environment recently…
            Yes.
            What was the change in environment you ask? …
            Well if your on enenews. There is a vast scientific community that can answer your query.

            So I ask you all.
            Am I wrong to suspect what I suspect.
            Can you prove me wrong?

            If not.

            be prepared.

            Because I see no larger indication of all hell breaking loose; Than multiple mega-ton animals perishing from radioactive contamination…

            What other evidence could better present the idea; That Indeed at the present time and day The Shit has already hit the fan…?’

            We are all in deep Kimchi!!!


            Report comment

          • midwestern midwestern

            I think you posted this link here earlier, xdrfox, from International Program on State of the Ocean?
            http://www.stateoftheocean.org/ipso-2011-workshop-summary.cfm

            “The 27 participants from 18 organisations in 6 countries produced a grave assessment of current threats — and a stark conclusion about future risks to marine and human life if the current trajectory of damage continues: that the world’s ocean is at high risk of entering a phase of extinction of marine species unprecedented in human history.”


            Report comment

          • Out of the numbers of seals tested, “only five had a virus” as the numbers of porpose from the gulf were tested and “only five had a virus” ! In the headlines last week !

            NOAA: New England Dead Seals Test Positive For Flu

            Nov 5, 2011 … (see Isolation of an influenza A virus from seals G. Lang, A. Gagnon and J. R.
            Geraci) … had determined that at least 5 of the dead seals had tested positive for
            an … Samples from the five seals has tested positive for the Influenza A virus, …
            Even though preliminary results have been received, they are only …
            http://afludiary.blogspot.com/2011/11/noaa-new-england-dead-seals-test.html

            Nov 2, 2011 … My guess is that the scientists actually doing the work had to stage a near … dead
            dolphins and whales never wash ashore so what is counted only … Five of the
            more than 500 dolphins that have washed ashore dead …. Five carcasses from Mississippi and one from Alabama have been tested for the virus, …
            http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/11/02/1032406/-Gulf-Watchers-Wednesday-Researches-expect-more-dolphin-deaths-BP-Catastrophe-AUV-567


            Report comment

  • WindorSolarPlease

    I have a feeling if the highest rating was a 10 it would be that, and so on.

    I believe this is the worst disaster that will effect everyone. It’s in the ocean and the jet stream, it will/has spread.

    Risk to Great ~ End Nuclear Power


    Report comment

    • Johnny Blade Johnny Blade

      And they’d still have to contend with the massive continuing buid-up of nuclear waste that’s “contained”(for now)in all of the countries who use nuclear technology.And that still WOULDN’T be enough to avert impending doom!!-even if it’s a damn good place to start,they have to continue working to develop methods of either “neutralizing” the widespread contamination or some viable method of collecting long-lived ground & water depositions & concentrations for storage until some breakthrough technology becomes available to deal with it!! Forgive me for saying this,but-I personally prefer any species of the animal world over “most” of my fellow humanoid counterparts!People have a choice in matters and ability to chart our own destiny-the poor animals being sickened & dying via our toxic contribution to the environment we share and the animal kingdom adapts to natural hardships while we try to alter & thus destroy anything we touch! The lowly cockroach suddenly becomes a noble life form when compared to TEPCO executives and those foul members of the offending industries & their lobbyist’s & Govt. supporter’s!~It sucks being alive & present for the mass extinction event for which we are both the cause & victim! I need a break from reality pouring from this sites pages for a little while-I’m having trouble trying to process everything going down…I can read Time.com’s “good news”(what a joke)about the 10% of Chernobyl bullshit and enjoy a moment in fantasyland unless someone pinches or slaps me back to consciousness again!! PEACE


      Report comment

  • “I don’t think (they) calculated common cause effects on multiple units…” – Rebecca Sigmon

    “This will be fascinating to review…” – Rebecca Sigmon

    How ‘fascinating’ is it now, after 8 months, Rebecca? I wonder if she has kids and if she gives them plenty of milk with their Frosted Flakes after they come in from playing in the rain or snow? I think Ms. Sigmon should go to Fukushima for a ‘hands on’ review of the situation. If I were her boss she would be on a plane ride right now.


    Report comment

  • @ James Tekton

    You have mail in your email box that you contacted me from;)


    Report comment


  • Up to 12 million bees found dead in Florida and no one knows why


    Authorities have already ruled out disease, including the infamous “Colony Collapse Disorder” (CCD), as the cause of a recent honeybee holocaust that took place in Brevard County, Florida. The UK’s Daily Mail reports that up to 12 million bees from roughly 800 apiaries in the area all dropped dead at roughly the same time around September 26 — and local beekeepers say pesticides are likely to blame. CCD is the term often used to describe the inexplicable mass die-off of honeybees around the world, which typically involves honeybees leaving their hives and, for whatever reason, never finding their way back home. Mass die-offs associated with CCD often occur at seemingly random locations around the world, and typically involve a gradual process of disappearance and eventual colony collapse — and the dead bees are typically nowhere to be found. But the recent Florida event involved hundreds of colonies from 30 different sites in a one-and-a-half mile radius literally dropping dead all at the same time and leaving their carcasses behind, which is why authorities have dismissed CCD as the cause. Based on the appearance of the dead bees, as well as the synchronous timing of their deaths, pesticide sprayings appear to be the culprit in this case. “I’m a pretty tough guy, but it is heart wrenching,” said Charles Smith of Smith Family Honey Company to News 13 in Orlando. His family’s company lost an estimated $150,000 worth of bees in the recent die-off. “Not only is it a monetary loss here, but we work really hard on these bees to keep them in good health.” The Florida die-off coincides with a recent county-wide mosquito eradication effort, during which helicopters flew over various parts of the county and sprayed airborne pesticides. Officials, of course, deny that this taxpayer-funded spraying initiative had anything to do with the bee genocide, though.


    Report comment

  • westcoastgirl westcoastgirl

    That is, Taco…


    Report comment

    • If this cycle continues, World anarchy will ensue. As soon as next spring millions of Crops will fail to pollenate; As well as oceanic product being vastly contaminative…
      All this will be Leading to mass food shortages. Trading internationally will be deeply impacted. Millions will starve all across the globe. Civil unrest will lead to rioting and civil wars. Nations will crumble and Humanity will fall if matters continue to head in this direction. OWS is a symptom. Vein as it may sound. Were experiencing a paradigm shift in trust and governance. The mice are in the corner, and the cat awaits its prey.

      Soon the cookies will crumble…

      As: All is not well in funky town.


      Report comment

  • I know when I was a kid, forty years ago I would see a lot of bees and quite a few wasps. Last couple of summers I see a lot of wasps and no bees. Bees are needed to produce fruit and to pollinate many wild plants.

    Back to NRC. What motivates them to be quiet about a very bad nuclear disaster outside of their country? Secret payola from GE?

    To all you Americans. Don’t be badmouthing the Japanese. Your just one earthquake away from a similar disaster. It is well documented that NRC suffers from regulatory capture. I’m Canadian and I don’t see us Canadians doing anything better except we have less people therefore less reactors. Regulatory Capture is alive and well throughout all governments right down to the municipalities rubber stamping housing developments which add traffic and other problems to the taxpayers who voted them in…..
    We all have a hand in this as we have chosen our personal comfort over uncomfortable protest.

    Its an evil world, God Bless


    Report comment

  • Hilarious. They actually call it ‘high quality global journalism’:

    High quality global journalism requires investment. Please share this article with others using the link below, do not cut & paste the article. See our Ts&Cs and Copyright Policy for more detail. Email ftsales.support@ft.com to buy additional rights. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/47e28ce0-093b-11e1-a20c-00144feabdc0.html#ixzz1e4ExdFV3

    But science and medical theory do indeed suggest Tokyo’s radiation levels are not something to worry too much about, not least because of the distance between the capital and Fukushima Daiichi. A little caesium-134 or 137 here or there should certainly not prevent visitors from enjoying what continues to be one of the world’s most vibrant capitals, packed with traditional culture and cutting-edge entertainment. In the past few days I have been invited to a techno event heavily promoted with nice post-modern irony as a “secret party”, and enjoyed demonstrations of the archaic samurai martial arts in central Tokyo’s beautiful Meiji shrine park.

    A 20-minute test of my Fukushima rice yielded the same reassuring result. Now there is nothing to stop me enjoying my fresh Fukushima rice in the knowledge that I’m also supporting a regional economy reeling from the combined effect of the tsunami and nuclear crisis. I only wish I had bought more.


    Report comment

    • Misitu

      Happy not to be a reader of this journal, then… thanks for the snip. I would suppose our “financial wizards” will naively be jetting off for a jolly in radland soon. Like hell they will.

      These are the folks that like to bet BIG time [with your pension pot] and wrecked the world money market as a side dish. Ha, ha. They might be arrogant and greedy but they are in no way unaware of what’s been happening around Tokyo recently

      No, maybe the reporter, being a little out of favour with his editor, got the free Japanese holiday as a kind of hidden punishment.

      What an idiot!


      Report comment

  • john lh john lh

    Japan’s famousTV host has Leukemia ,after eat lots of food from FUKUSHIMA on his program since 3.11

    This TV host has been foud Leukemia ,after eat lots of food from FUKUSHIMA on his program since 3.11.

    Together with beatuy.

    This Chinese language link:http://www.wenxuecity.com/news/2011/11/18/1538313.html


    Report comment

  • ExposeEvil OriginalSinRising

    http://www.examiner.com/human-rights-in-national/experts-fukushima-off-scale-lethal-radiation-level-100s-millions-deaths

    - ” If noticing unusual amounts of hair falling out, confusion, nose bleeds or other odd symptoms typical of radiation sickness, it might be due to the United States’ record high levels of radiation.”

    This evidence seamlessly correlates volumes of information indicating practice of intentional eugenics warfare to achieve biological destruction and economic sabotage of global human activity conducted by the elitist corporate cabal of interbred hereditary plutocrats acting as planetary dictators in supreme malevolent satanic technocracy.


    Report comment