Officials: Giant sinkhole NOT growing — Only “appearance of growth” (PHOTOS & VIDEOS)

Published: October 20th, 2012 at 12:26 pm ET
By
Email Article Email Article
21 comments


Title: 9:00 a.m. Update
Source: Assumption Parish Police Jury
Date: Oct. 20, 2012

Clean up continues today at the sinkhole site.

We’ve received many inquiries regarding the flyover videos posted on yesterday – specific to the growth towards the pipeline right of way. This appearance of growth is due to hydrocarbon contaminated vegetative debris being removed and wasn’t caused by a sinking or slough-in of the hole. Floating grass that can be seen all along the pipeline right of way was removed (on the direct perimeter of the sinkhole) during clean up efforts.

Are they saying this new area was already considered part of the sinkhole? If so, why is it not included within the border of the sinkhole on the most current sinkhole dimensions map?

To view the latest changes in the sinkhole, see:

Published: October 20th, 2012 at 12:26 pm ET
By
Email Article Email Article
21 comments

Related Posts

  1. Latest flyover footage shows giant Louisiana sinkhole taking on new appearance (PHOTOS & VIDEOS) October 19, 2012
  2. Comparison photos show significant sinkhole growth on other side of gas pipeline — WAFB: It’s continuing to grow; Company: No change in size (PHOTOS) October 15, 2012
  3. Officials: ‘Growth event’ underway at giant sinkhole — Salt may be shifting underground — Site evacuated, equipment removed — Oxy 3 well pad in jeopardy (MAP) January 19, 2013
  4. New official map of giant sinkhole dimensions shows significant growth (PHOTO) October 14, 2012
  5. New flyover of giant Louisiana sinkhole shows changing appearance (VIDEOS) December 7, 2012

21 comments to Officials: Giant sinkhole NOT growing — Only “appearance of growth” (PHOTOS & VIDEOS)

  • Anthony Anthony

    I imagine the floating grass therefore is floating on a sinkhole?


    Report Comment

  • Usefulbreather

    Ignore that giant perimeter of dead Cypress Trees that have stood over the bayou for centuries. That's just "contaminated vegetative debris" as well.


    Report Comment

  • jec

    The Assumpton Parish update..they are "still testing"..not providing information to residents or evacuees. See:
    http://www.edsuite.com/proposals/proposals_280/assumption_update_october_19-2012_fi_503.pdf
    Note the changes for this report are in red..and the amount of tests without any responses to the victims….

    This will certain shove more people into legal (Lawyers!) action. And with the minimal wording of the Texas Brine documents on evacuee asssistance-it would make ANYONE worried. Wonder what government official signed off on the TEXAS BRINE boilerplate..and what other companies also use the same wording? Lots of cookie cutter documents I bet…


    Report Comment

  • dosdos dosdos

    Keep in mind that the official differentiate between the hole and the subsidence region. The hole goes down hundreds of feet. The subsidence area only goes down a few feet, though with all the oil present, it's difficult to determine depth visually from above. They have to use sounding line or electronic depth finders to determine that.

    The subsidence area is sinking and taking on oil and water, but it's not part of the hole as the officials determine it. The hole is caused by the failure of the cavern, whereas the subsidence is caused by a shifting of the cap of the dome or a compression of strata from pressure release (oil release, etc), dropping the whole area a few feet.

    So when the officials speak, don't equate surface area with the hole area.

    The hole will grow in the future, rest assured on that. There will be more collapse of the cavern to swallow it down. But the subsidence area will grow faster. It has already spread to the area of most of the dead cypress tress, even if the water/contaminants are not yet visible on the surface. It's just a matter of time.


    Report Comment

  • Cisco Cisco

    Yeah right…Are you going to believe the officials or your lying eyes!


    Report Comment

  • krugthecaveman krugthecaveman

    My comment posted to the wrong story, prob my bad as first time talker loooong time follower. They already know how big this thing is gonna be. We don't, but you can bet they do! They have years/trigs of data. Plenty of quantum computers to process.


    Report Comment

    • VicFromOregon VicFromOregon

      Hi krugthecaveman, welcome. We know that they have brought in international experts because it was puzzling, and there is so much going on in that little area with the various drilling, storing, extracting. Unfortunately, until quite recently because of this event, TexasBrine had been operating on outdated geologic maps, which helped bring about this event. The hadn't wanted to pay for a copy of the surveys that had been done. Thx to PavewayIII, Mark and others for this info! I agree, they have a sense of the scope of this, and if push comes to shove, they will simply cap off the wells, retrieve the stored hydrocarbons, not sure what they would do with fracking chemicals, and, then, cement it. My concern is that none of this stuff will remain in impermanent holes and human made caverns forever. Especially the fracking fluid which is corrosive and has a lower viscosity than the oil. Maybe generations, but, it will eventually move, as does all fluid.


      Report Comment

      • PavewayIII PavewayIII

        Vic – the only place I have ever seen anything about fracking fluid in this particular cavern has been a rumor started (as far as I can tell) right here on ENENews.

        Texas Brine has never pulled a permit for this as a disposal well and it just doesn't make sense that they would use it for that. They might have dozens of other disposal wells in some salt dome somewhere that they used for fracking waste disposal (no idea), but I've just never seen any evidence of this here.

        They had to pull a different kind of a permit to reinject their NORM pipe scale as most brine wells eventually do, but this does not change the basic class of the well from a brine well to a disposal well. And of course I'm just talking regulated activity and what they could or are suppose to do. I wouldn't expect them to document their own illegal activity, but surely someone must have some basis for the repeated 'fracking fluid' suggestions here.


        Report Comment

  • Usefulbreather

    The truth is everyone involved is now just a spectator. No expert will ever really know its true cause or be allowed to reveal it and consequently how to fix it. Like Lake Peigneur in 1980, we all just have to watch it grow. Remember that when water comes in contact with salt, it liquifies…how much salt is down there?


    Report Comment

  • krugthecaveman krugthecaveman

    I just mean that all of the officials involved are saying that the sinkhole is not growing. We think it is by the looks of the latest flyovers. Shows they know big it will be them.


    Report Comment

  • kalidances

    At this point I think certain members of Texas Brine, the Texas government, and Louisiana government are probably booking very long "holiday vacation trips" overseas (and in places where they cannot be indicted) and will never face trial.
    For non-US folk this will give you an idea of how the weather can be near the sinkhole area:
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_Atlantic_hurricane_season#November.2C_December.2C_and_January


    Report Comment

  • Urban27

    Well I use to use a laser to measure exact ladscape. One laser a bit away. Let's say two or three hundred feet away pointing its beam on to a stick that is stuck safe in the ground as close the hole as possible. Or in the watery ground a bit out in the "hole" Than it would show if the land is sinking or not. But you have to be rather sure that the laser is not standing on a new hole. And see to that the stick is fixed in the wet ground.

    Maybe the hole in the ground somewhere down there is not growing, but the wet area is defiantly growing – that is no question about that.
    Maybe they will try to make people feel safe, not so many people are looking so deep into things – many don't care for reading anything but the local stuff..


    Report Comment

  • PurpleRain

    This is SO RIDICULOUS!~ They are just being ass#oles talking down to the public now!


    Report Comment

  • Fury Fury

    HMMMM!!??? If the ground is sinking, doesn't that make it part of the "sink" hole!!!??


    Report Comment

  • Fury Fury

    also if it's brine disposal where did all the oil come from? is there really that much oil in drilling brine? nd if not is there a natural oilformation leaking into this?? Or is the pipeline cracked and leaking? Maybe for a long time and caused the ground to wash off into the hole and into the cavern? Hmmm??


    Report Comment

  • Fury Fury

    "The Lousiana Black EYE", The Sink hole", "Watch it grow live" "$1.oo an hour, stay as long as you like.' ' No Insurance, You're on your own!!" Please. This IS America!! Somebody make some money off of this!!


    Report Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.