Today, Syracuse University professor Thomas J. Csermely argued there is no increased risk of childhood cancer in the vicinity of nuclear reactors. Perhaps this recently published study in the International Journal of Cancer will help him when making such arguments in the future.
Title: Childhood leukemia around French nuclear power plants – the Geocap study, 2002-2007
Source: International Journal of Cancer
Authors: Claire Sermage-Faure, Dominique Laurier, Stéphanie Goujon-Bellec, Michel Chartier, Aurélie Guyot-Goubin, Jérémie Rudant, Denis Hémon, Jacqueline Clavel
Date: Accepted Jan. 5 2012
To study the risk of childhood acute leukemia (AL) around French nuclear power plants (NPPs).
The nationwide Geocap case-control study included the 2,753 cases diagnosed in mainland France over 2002-2007 and 30,000 contemporaneous population controls. The last addresses were geocoded and located around the 19 NPPs. The study used distance to NPPs and a dose-based geographic zoning (DBGZ), based on the estimated dose to bone marrow related to NPP gaseous discharges.
An odds ratio (OR) of 1.9 [1.0-3.3], based on 14 cases, was evidenced for children living within 5 km of NPPs, compared to those living 20 km or further away, and a very similar association was observed in the concomitant incidence study (standardized incidence ratio (SIR) = 1.9 [1.0-3.2]). These results were similar for all the 5-year age groups. They persisted after stratification for several contextual characteristics of the municipalities of residence. Conversely, using the DBGZ resulted in OR and SIR close to one in all of the dose categories. There was no increase in AL incidence over 1990-2001 and over the entire 1990-2007 period. The results suggest a possible excess risk of AL in the close vicinity of French NPPs in 2002-2007. The absence of any association with the DBGZ may indicate that the association is not explained by NPP gaseous discharges. Overall, the findings call for investigation for potential risk factors related to the vicinity of NPP, and collaborative analysis of multisite studies conducted in various countries.
Read the abstract here
- Reuters: Child leukaemia doubles near French nuclear plants says gov't study -- Result is statistically significant -IRSN expert
- Syracuse Professor: "Chernobyl had an exemplary operating record prior to the accident" -- Claims new reactors "inherently safe" -- No increased childhood cancer near NPPs -- US gov't spends "hundreds of billions" on renewable energy
Read the full IJC article here
Published: January 21st, 2012 at 3:44 pm ET
- U.S. University Study: 23% higher incidence of childhood leukemia within 16 km of nuclear facilities… More January 30, 2012
- Mag: Evidence linking nuclear plants to ill health increasingly compelling, “clear something is going” says prof. — UK gov’t blames unidentified virus for childhood leukemia rise February 15, 2012
- German Gov’t Study: Children living near nuclear plants have double leukemia rates, high incidence of solid cancers — Reactors cannot prevent radiation from escaping (VIDEO) October 22, 2011
- Reuters: Child leukaemia doubles near French nuclear plants says gov’t study — Result is statistically significant -IRSN expert January 12, 2012
- Study on IAEA website: Core meltdown risk now around 1,000% higher because of Fukushima — Engineer: Nuclear disaster “a certainty” over next 30 years in Europe November 2, 2013